Write a reply that hands a case to a human agent
What this does
This playbook helps a support team write a customer reply and an internal handoff note in one step. You paste the customer message, the policy and your escalation rules. The AI suggests whether a person is needed, writes a reply that promises nothing the policy does not allow, and records the reason, urgency and what was already tried.
On this page
Before and after
Before
- An agent reads the message, looks up the policy, decides whether to pass the case on and writes a reply.
- The handoff note is often a single line, so the next agent asks the customer the same questions again.
- Replies sometimes promise a refund or date that the policy does not allow.
After
- The agent pastes the message, policy and rules, and gets a decision, a draft reply and a structured note in one pass.
- The agent checks the decision, settles who leads the case and checks the promises, then sends.
- The next person can pick up the case from the note without going back to the customer.
Saves about 5 minutes per escalated case

From my practice
I see handoffs go wrong when the customer is promised something the next agent has to undo. A good reply says what happens next and who does it, and leaves out refunds and dates the policy does not allow. The note should save the agent from asking the customer the same questions again. A person reads both before sending.
What to have ready
- The customer message, pasted as received, with details you do not need (full address, card or bank details) removed.
- The policy text that applies to this case, such as returns, refunds, delivery or warranty, copied from your own document.
- Your escalation rules: when an agent must take over, who receives the case and how urgent each type is.
- Case facts from your helpdesk or order system: dates, order value, earlier contacts and anything already tried.
- The channel (email, WhatsApp or chat), the tone you want and how you sign off.
Build your prompt
- 1. Gather your inputsHave the items above to hand.
- 2. Fill in the formYour prompt updates as you type.
- 3. Copy or open in your AIClaude, ChatGPT or Gemini.
- 4. Review before you sendCheck it against your notes.
Your prompt · 0 of 6 filled
Gemini cannot be filled from a link, so the prompt is copied first. Paste it with Ctrl+V or Cmd+V.
Use it as a skill
Add this playbook to your assistant once, then ask for it by name.
How to install
- Claude: download the zip and upload it as is under Settings, Capabilities, Skills.
- Other assistants: open SKILL.md, copy it, and paste it into the assistant's custom instructions or project.
- Ask for the playbook by its task, and give it your details when it asks.
The skill is plain text with no scripts, links or commands. Read SKILL.md before you install it, and use a company-approved AI workspace. Need help setting it up? Book a call.
See a real result
Sample input: Kaveri Home Appliances, Pune · Hi, I ordered a mixer grinder (order KHA-20418) and the… · Customer: Rohan Mehta. Order KHA-20418, Rs…
1. Decision: Handoff needed. Three escalation rules apply:
- The customer mentions a consumer forum (legal mention), so this goes to the support manager.
- The report is outside the 7-day window, so this goes to the returns team lead.
- The order value is above Rs 5,000 and a refund is requested.
2. Reply to customer:
Subject: Your cracked mixer grinder jar – order KHA-20418
Dear Rohan,
I'm sorry your mixer grinder jar arrived cracked. Thank you for letting us know.
Our damage-on-delivery policy asks for reports within 7 days of delivery, and your order was delivered on 6 November. Because of this, I have passed your case to our support manager and returns team lead, who will review it and decide the next steps. I can't confirm a refund, replacement or dispatch date myself, as those decisions sit with them.
To help them, please reply with a clear photo of the cracked jar.
Thank you for your patience.
Warm regards, Kaveri Support Team
3. Handoff note for the agent:
Reason: Three escalation rules apply:
- Consumer forum mentioned (legal mention, goes to support manager).
- Report made 9 days after delivery, outside the 7-day window (goes to returns team lead).
- Order value Rs 6,499 is above Rs 5,000 and a refund is requested.
Urgency: High. The customer has mentioned a consumer forum and wants action by "tomorrow".
Customer wants: Full refund and a new jar sent by tomorrow. He says he will go to the consumer forum if it isn't sorted.
Already tried: Order and delivery record checked (KHA-20418, Rs 6,499, UPI, delivered 6 Nov 2026). This is the first contact on this issue and no earlier reply was sent. No photo has been received.
Policy points that apply:
- Damage must be reported within 7 days of delivery with a photo. The window ended on 13 Nov, and today is 15 Nov.
- Reports after 7 days need manager approval.
- After inspection, the returns team replaces the item or refunds to the original payment method.
- Refunds take 5 to 7 working days after the returned item reaches us.
- Only the returns team confirms replacement dispatch dates.
What the customer has been told:
- He has been acknowledged and told the report is past the 7-day window.
- The support manager and returns team lead will review the case.
- He has been asked for a photo of the cracked jar.
- No refund, replacement, exception, date or timeline has been promised, and the forum threat was not addressed or argued with.
Suggested next step for the agent:
- Support manager to own the case because of the forum mention. Returns team lead to decide on the out-of-window request.
- Get the manager approval that policy requires for late reports before anything is committed.
- Review the photo once it arrives.
- Reply to the customer with the decision. Only the returns team should confirm any replacement dispatch date.
Open questions:
- Will the manager approve an exception, given the customer says he was travelling? There is no proof of this and the policy has no travel exception.
- The policy says "manager approval" and the escalation rules say "returns team lead". [ASSUMED] Both the support manager and the returns team lead should be involved. Please confirm who gives the final approval.
- The customer asked for both a full refund and a new jar. The policy offers replacement or refund, not both, so which should be offered if approved?
- Will the customer send a photo? Without one, the policy requirement is not met.
- Does the cracked jar need to be returned for inspection? The policy implies this but does not say how.
-
Decision: Handoff needed — Consumer forum mention; report outside 7-day window; refund requested on an order above Rs 5,000.
-
Reply to customer:
Dear Rohan,
I’m sorry the jar in your mixer grinder order KHA-20418 arrived cracked. I understand you were travelling and are reporting this nine days after delivery.
As this is outside our 7-day reporting window, manager approval is needed. I’m referring your case to our support manager and returns team lead to review your request for a full refund and a new jar by tomorrow.
Please send a photo showing the cracked jar. We cannot confirm a refund or replacement at this stage, and only our returns team can confirm any replacement dispatch date.
Kaveri Support Team
- Handoff note for the agent
Reason: Consumer forum mention requires support manager escalation. Outside-window report requires returns team lead review and manager approval. Rs 6,499 order with a refund request also triggers handoff.
Urgency: High — Customer mentioned taking the matter to the consumer forum.
Customer wants: Full refund and a new jar sent by tomorrow.
Already tried: Checked order and delivery record. First contact on this issue; no earlier reply sent. No photo received.
Policy points that apply:
- Damage must be reported within 7 days of delivery with a photo.
- Delivered 6 Nov 2026; reported 15 Nov 2026, nine days later. Manager approval is required.
- After returns-team inspection, the policy allows replacement or refund, not a confirmed entitlement to both.
- Refunds go to the original payment method, UPI here, and take 5–7 working days after the returned item reaches us.
- Only the returns team confirms replacement dispatch dates.
What the customer has been told: A photo is needed; the support manager and returns team lead will review the request. Manager approval is required. No refund, replacement or dispatch date has been confirmed.
Suggested next step for the agent: Route to the support manager as High priority and involve the returns team lead. Obtain the damage photo, seek approval for the late report, and review the requested remedies before confirming any outcome.
Open questions: Can the customer provide a photo of the cracked jar? Will the manager approve the late report? What remedy can be offered after review and inspection?
Was this playbook helpful?
Want this set up for your team?
I can fit this playbook into your CRM, helpdesk or inbox and train your team to use it.
Book a 30-minute reviewReview before you send
Watch out for
Over-promising. the AI may try to calm the customer by offering a refund or a date. Check every commitment in the reply against the policy and delete any the policy does not allow.
Several rules at once. a legal mention, a late report and a high order value can all apply to one case, each with a different owner. The AI tends to list them together. A person should decide who leads so the case does not sit between two teams.
Quiet assumptions. the AI may turn 'tomorrow' into a date or read a limit into the policy that is not written there. These look like facts in the note, so check them against the source.
Personal data. customer messages can hold phone numbers, addresses and payment details. Remove what the AI does not need, use an approved workspace, and follow your obligations under India's DPDP Act or GDPR. This is general guidance and not legal advice.
Wrong urgency. the AI judges from the text you give it. If a safety issue or legal threat is missing from your escalation rules, the AI will not flag it. Keep the rules complete and current.
Rubber-stamping. if agents send replies without reading them, errors reach customers. Ask reviewers to check four things each time: the decision, the lead owner, the promises and the facts in the note.
Outdated policy. the AI follows the policy you paste. Paste the current version each time, not an old copy from a chat history.
Tips for your industry
This playbook works for any business. These notes help you adapt it.
Damaged items, late deliveries and refund requests are the usual handoff triggers. Order value, days since delivery and payment method are the facts agents most often need in the note.
Outages, billing disputes and data requests need a human quickly. Include the plan, the account owner and what the customer has already tried in the product.
Complaints, disputed transactions and anything touching account security should go to a person with the right authority. Keep account numbers and identity details out of the prompt.
Booking changes, billing disagreements and guest complaints often depend on a stay date. Put the date and the cancellation terms in the case details so the reply does not promise a rate or room.
Questions people ask
It suggests, and your escalation rules guide it. A person should confirm the decision before the reply goes out, especially when the AI says no handoff is needed. Cases involving safety, legal threats or large amounts should always be read by a human.
The prompt tells the AI to say that a colleague will review the case and to give no date. The handoff note lists the gap under open questions. The agent or manager then decides, and you may want to add the new case to your policy.
The AI will usually list every rule that applies. Before sending, a person picks the lead owner and notes who else needs to know. If this happens often, add a line to your escalation rules that says which team leads when rules overlap.
Only if your company has approved the tool and you share the minimum needed. Remove phone numbers, full addresses and payment details first. Check your obligations under the DPDP Act or GDPR with someone qualified.
Last checked · Updated